Soviet statistics as a historical source

Abstract

The main purpose of the article is to identify capabilities of soviet statistics as a historical source. Basic information on this type of historical sources is represented. The article is concerned with a significant tradition of the soviet society studying. Research methods: comparative, logical, historical, analysis and synthesis, systematic, historical-genetic, method of historiographical image. Main results. The article describes a large toolkit for working with statistics: mathematical correction of censuses, research on falsifications and political pressure. A number of themes are considered including soviet statistics as mass historical source. The article reports on relevance and accessibility of soviet statistics nowadays. Concise conclusions. Ukrainian and foreign historians have created a large number of conceptual reviews of Soviet statistics. The author outlines some classification types of soviet statistics. It is specially noted on little-known aspects of soviet sources studying. Special attention is given to the verification of statistics of the USSR for authenticity and representativeness.  Internet sites with open access to soviet statistics are considered. The paper studies leading concepts about changing the accounting of economic and demographic indicators of Soviet Union. Stalin era is described as main factor in the development of soviet statistics. The article reveals this concept and scrutinize it critique in historiography. Practical significance: recommended for use by authors of articles about the economic and the population history. Originality: the practical experience of scientific research and reference materials devoted to the features of  statistical (mass) sources is generalized. Scientific novelty: the first of proposed the image of development soviet statistics with source problems in historiography. The formation of central and local statistic bodies in Ukrainian and foreign studies is described. The article reveals the main statistic sources and scrutinize their critique in historiography. Article type: descriptive.

Author Biography

Yevhen Kravchenko, Oles Honchar Dnipro National University

Master of History and Archeology, Postgraduate Student, Department of Historiography, Source Studies and Archival Studies, Faculty of History, Oles Honchar Dnipro National University, Dnipro, Ukraine.

References

Andreev, E., Darskij, T., and T. Har’kova, T., 1998. Demograficheskaja istorija Rossii: 1927–1959 [Demographic history of Russia: 1927–1959]. Moscow: Informatika (in Russian).

Bljum, A., and Mespule, M., 2006. Bjurokraticheskaja anarhija. Statistika i vlast’ pri Staline [Bureaucratic anarchy. Statistics and power under Stalin]. Moscow: ROSSPEN (in Russian).

Central’niy derzhavnij arhіv gromads’kih obiednan’ [Central State Archive of Public Associations], 2001. Guidebook. Kyiv.

Davies, R., and Wheachcroft, S., 1994. The crooked mirror of Soviet economic statistics. In: Davies, R., Harrison, M., and Wheachcroft, S., eds., 1994. The economic transformation of the Soviet Union, 1913–1945. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, рp. 24–38.

Gejer, M., 2011. Vvvedenie. Posle totalitarizma. Sravnitel’nyj analiz stalinizma i nacizma [Introduction After totalitarianism. Comparative analysis of Stalinism and Nazism.]. In: Gejer, M., and Ficpatrik, Sh., eds., 2011. Za ramkami totalitarizma. Sravnitel’nye issledovanija stalinizma i nacizma [Outside of totalitarianism. Comparative studies of Stalinism and Nazism]. Moscow: Rossijskaja politicheskaja jenciklopedija (ROSSPEN); Fond Pervogo Prezidenta Rossii B. N. El’cina, рp. 6–51 (in Russian).

Graziosi, A., 1999. The new Soviet archival sources. Cahiers du monde russe. Cahiers du monde russe, no. 40(1–2), рp. 13–63.

Istoricheskie materialy [Historical materials]. Available at: http://istmat.info/statistics (Accessed 11 March 2019).

Kabanov, V., 1998. Istoricheskie istochniki sovetskogo perioda [Historical sources of the Soviet period]. In: Danilevskij, I., Kabanov, V., Medushevskaja O., and Rumjanceva, M., eds., 1998. Teorija. Istorija. Metod. Istochniki rossijskoj istorii [Theory. History. Method. Sources of Russian History]. Tutorial. Moscow, рp. 582–605 (in Russian).

Kalakura, Ja., Voycehіvs’ka, І., Pavlenko, S., Korol’ov, І., and Palіenko, M., 2002. Іstorichne dzhereloznavstvo [Historical Source Studies]. Tutorial. Kyiv: Lybіd’.

Korchak-Chepurkіvs’kij, Ju., 1929. Tablycі dozhivannja ta spodіvanogo zhittja ljudnostі USRR 1925–1926 [The tables of life and the expected life of the people of the USSR 1925–1926s]. Kharliv: CSU USRR (in Ukrainian).

Koval’chenko, I., and Bovykin, V., eds., 1979. Massovye istochniki po social’no‑ekonomicheskoj istorii Rossii perioda kapitalizma [Mass sources on the socio‑economic history of Russia in the period of capitalism]. Moscow: Nauka (in Russian).

Koval’chenko, I., ed., 1979. Massovye istochniki po social’no‑ekonomicheskoj istorii sovetskogo obshhestva [Mass sources on the socio‑economic history of soviet society]. Moscow: Izdatelstvo Moskowskoho universiteta.

Lubskij, A., and Pronshtejn, A., 1981. Nekotorye teoreticheskie i metodicheskie problemy istochnikovedenija massovyh istochnikov [Some theoretical and methodological problems of source study of mass sources]. In: Buganov, V., ed., 1981. Istochnikoedenie otechestvennoj istorii [Source study of national history]. Moscow: Nauka, рp. 3–36 (in Russian).

Materialy ob okazanii pomoshhi golodajushhemu naseleniju Pavlogradskogo rajona (svedenija, perepiski) [Materials on rendering assistance to the starving population of the Pavlograd district (information, correspondence)], 1933. File 81. Inventory 1. Fund 2240. State Archive of Dnipropetrovska oblast (in Russian).

Nіkols’kij, V., 2003. Represyvna dijal’nist’ organiv derzhavnoi bezpeki SRSR v Ukraini (kinec’ 1920-h-1950-ti rr.). [The repressive activity of the state bodies security of the USSR in Ukraine (late 1920s – 1950s)]. Historical and statistical research. From archives VUChK‑GPU‑NKVD‑KGB, issue 1, р. 91 (in Ukrainian).

Otchet o provedenii Vsesojuznoj perepisi naselenija 1939 g. na territori Dnepropetrovskoj i Zaporozhskoj oblasti [Report on the conduct of the All‑ Union Population Census of 1939 in the territory of Dnipropetrovsk and Zaporizhia regions], 1939. File 3. Inventory 29. Fund 2493. State Archive of Dnipropetrovska oblast (in Russian).

Poljakov, Ju., Vodarskij, Ja., and Zhiromskaja, V., ed., 1991. Vsesojuznaja perepis’ naselenija 1937 g. Kratkie itogi [1937 All‑Union Population Census. Summary]. Moscow: Institut istorii SSSR (in Russian).

Rumjanceva, M., 1998. Massovye istochniki [Mass sources]. In: Danilevskij, I., Kabanov, V., Medushevskaja, O., and Rumjanceva, M., eds., 1998. Teorija. Istorija. Metod. Istochniki rossijskoj istorii: Ucheb. [Theory. History. Method. Sources of Russian History]. Guedebook. Moscow, рp. 331–335 (in Russian).

Rusina, Ju., 2015. Istochnikovedenie novejshej istorii Rossii [Source study of the modern history of Russia]. Guidebook. Ekaterinburg (in Russian).

Sbornik statisticheskih materialov (v pomoshh’ agitatoru i propagandistu) [Collection of statistical materials (help for the agitator and propagandist)], 1986. Moscow: Finansy i statistika (in Russian).

Seltzer, W., 1994. Politics and statistics: independence, dependence or interaction? DESIPA working paper series, no. 6, рp. 1–45.

Shejnin, O., 2001. Statistika i ideologija v SSSR [Statistics and ideology in the USSR]. Zametki po evrejskoj istorii [Jewish history notes], no. 6 (41), рp. 179–198 (in Russian).

Spravochnik predsedatelja kolhoza [Directory of the chairman of the collective farm], 1941. Moscow: Selhozgiz (in Russian).

Tol’c, M., 2004. Tajny sovetskoj demografii [Secrets of the Soviet demography]. Demoskop Weekly. no. 171–172, рp. 1–16 (in Russian).

Voronov, V., 2003. Dzhereloznavstvo іstorіy Ukrainy [Source study of Ukranian history]. Lectures. Dnipropetrovsk (in Ukrainian).

Wheatcroft, S., 1992. Statistical sources for the study of soviet social history in the prewar period. In: Fitzpatrick, Sh., and Lynne, V., eds., 1992. A researcher’s guide to sources on soviet social history in 1930s. M. E. Sharpe, Inc, рp. 153–176.

White, C., 1964. Unkind cuts at statisticians. The American Statistician, no. 18 (5), рp. 15–17.
Published
2020-10-17
How to Cite
KRAVCHENKO, Yevhen. Soviet statistics as a historical source. Universum Historiae et Archeologiae = The Universe of History and Archeology = Універсум історії та археології = Универсум истории и археологии ISSN 2664-9950 (Print) ISSN 2707-6385 (Online), [S.l.], v. 2, n. 2, p. 262–270, oct. 2020. ISSN 2707-6385. Available at: <http://uha.dp.ua/index.php/UHA/article/view/69>. Date accessed: 22 oct. 2020. doi: https://doi.org/10.15421/26190220.
Section
Historiography. Source Study. Special Historical Disciplines