Narrative sources on the diplomatic game of European countries around the events of the Polish uprising of 1863

Abstract

The purpose of the article – to disclose the meaning of the difference between the official, publicly declared position and the real (national) interests of Western European countries regarding their attitude to January 1863 Polish Uprising. Research methods: are analysis and synthesis, comparative, deduction, generalization. Main results: are despite the official statements by Western European governments to support the Poles' demands during the uprising of 1863 (in satisfaction of the Russian empire of their national rights), no real efforts were made. This state of affairs is clarified, with a meticulous analysis of true intentions of foreign policy of European countries. In the context of the implementation of policy in the nineteenth century, European governments could no longer ignore public opinion. After all, in the nineteenth century there was the epoch of affirmation in Europe of the ideals of the French Revolution and the formation of the institutions of civil society (free press, trade unions, public organizations, political parties, etc.). Involving information from narrative sources on events of 1863 clearly reveals the peculiarities of foreign policy and convinces that, in making final decisions, governments of the countries were guided by their own national interests (and not by the mind of public). Therefore, the Polish uprising became an opportunity to compete for the redistribution of influences among the leading countries of Europe and the interests of the Poles turned out to be only an instrument for achieving completely different goals. Concise conclusions: are the support of Western European governments in the Polish uprising were driven by public demands, but the real goal of each of the countries involved diplomatically to address this problem was to strengthen their own political stance in international affairs on the continent. Practical significance: this article will contribute to a better understanding of complex issues when assessing the position of Western European countries in the international politics of the mid-nineteenth century. Originality: compares information from publicly-published and diplomatically-concealed sources. Scientific novelty: the knowledge about the significant difference between the diplomatic statements and the real intentions of the foreign policy efforts of the Western European countries in the international relations of the middle of the nineteenth century were supplemented. Article type: analytic.

Author Biographies

Yurii S. Zemskyi, Khmelnytskyi National University

D. Sc. in History, Professor, Professor of the Department of International Relations and Tourism of the Khmelnitsky National University

Valerii V. Diachok, Khmelnytskyi National University

PhD in History, Associate Professor, Associate Professor of the Department of International Relations and Tourism of the Khmelnitsky National University

References

Aksakov, I. S., 1863. Ne voyna, a obshchestvenna-ya sila Rossii mozhet reshat' o pol'skom voprose [Not war, but Russia's social power can decide on the Polish question]. In: Aksakov, I. S., 1886. Pol'skiy vopros i zapadno-russkoe delo. Evreyskiy vopros. 1860–1886. Stat'i iz "Dnya", "Moskvy", "Moskvicha" i "Rusi" [The Polish Question and the Western Russian Affair. Jewish question. 1860-1886. Articles from the Day, the Moscow, the Moskvich and the Rus]. In 3 vols. Moscow, vol. 3 (in Russian).

Berman'skiy, K. L., 1905. "Konstitutsionnye" proekty tsarstvovaniya Aleksandra II ["Constitutional" projects of the reign of Alexander II]. Vestnik prava [Herald of Law], vol. 9 (in Russian).

I-r, 1863. Chego oni tak ispugalis'? [Why are they so scared?]. Kolokol, no. 163, May 15 (in Russian).

Murav'ev, A. N., 1882. Graf Mikhail Nikolaevich Murav'ev. Zapiski ego ob upravlenii Severo-Zapadnym kraem i ob usmirenii v nem myatezha. 1863–1866 [Count Mikhail Nikolaevich Muravyov. His notes on the administration of the Northwest Territory and on the suppression of rebellion in it. 1863-1866]. Russkaya starina, November (in Russian).

Debidour, A., 1947. Ot Venskogo do Berlinskogo kongressa (1814–1878) [From Vienna to the Berlin Congress (1814–1878)]. In: Debidour, A., 1947. Diplomaticheskaya istoriya Evropy [The Diplomatic History of Europe]. In 2 vols. Moscow: State Publishing House of Foreign Literature, vol. 2 (in Russian).

Korsakov, D. A., 1899. Iz zhizni K. D. Kavelina vo Frantsii i Germanii v 1862–1864 gg. (Po ego perepiske v eto vremya) [From the life of K. D. Cavelin in France and Germany in 1862–1864 (According to his correspondence at this time).]. Russkaya mysl', vol. 11 (in Russian).

K., N., V., 1884. K istorii Pol'skogo vosstaniya 1863 g. (Depeshi ital'yanskogo posla pri russkom dvore, markiza Pepoli) [To the history of the Polish uprising of 1863 (The dispatches of the Italian ambassador to the Russian court, Marquis Pepoli)]. Istoricheskiy vestnik [Historical Bulletin], vol. 17 (July, August, September) (in Russian).

Katkov, M. N., 1887. 1863 god. Sobranie statey po Pol'skomu voprosu, pomeshchavshikhsya v Moskovskikh vedomostyakh, Russkom vestnike i Sovremennoy letopisi [Collection of articles on the Polish question, placed in the Moscow Gazette, the Russian Bulletin and the Modern Chronicle]. Moscow (in Russian).

Kornilov, A. A., 1915. Russkaya politika v Pol'she so vremen razdelov do nachala XX veka [Russian politics in Poland from the time of the partitions to the beginning of the 20th century]. Petrograd: Ogni (in Russian).

Revunenkov, V. G., 1957. Pol'skoe vosstanie 1863 g. i Evropeyskaya diplomatiya [The Polish uprising of 1863 and European diplomacy]. Leningrad: University of Leningrad Publishing House (in Russian).

Sidorov, A. A., 1903. Pol's'koe vosstanie 1863 goda. Istoricheskiy ocherk [The Polish uprising of 1863. Historical essay]. St.Petersburg (in Russian).

Głębocki, H., 2006. Irredenta polska a "kresy" imperium. Powstanie Styczniowe (1863–1864) a ewolucja polityki imperium Rosyjskiego wobec jego zachodnich "okrain". W: Nowak, Andrzej. Rosja i Europa wschodnia: imperiologia stosowana. Kraków (in Polish).

Łepkowski, T., 2003. Polska – narodziny nowoczesnego narodu. 1764-1870 [posłowiem opatrzył Jerzy Jedlicki]. Poznań: Wydawnictwo Poznańskiego towarzystwa przyjaciół nauk (in Polish).

Nowak, W., 2005. Terror wobec ludności cywilnej Królestwa Polskiego i Ziem Zabranych stosowany przez oddziały i żandarmerię powstańczą w latach 1863–1864. W: Caban Wiesław, Śliwowska Wiktoria, red. Powstanie Styczniowe 1863–1864. Walka i uczestnicy. Represji i wygnanie. Historiografia i tradycja. Kielce: Wydawnyctwo Akademii Świętokrzyskiej (in Polish).

Toporczyk, J., 1907. Powstanie 1863–1864 r. Warszawa (in Polish).

Łossowski, P., Młynarski, Z., 1959. Rosjanie, Białorusini i Ukraińcy w powśtaniu Styczniowym. Wrocław: Zakład Narodowy im. Ossolińskich (in Polish).

Wojnar, K, 1901. Powstanie narodowe w r. 1863 i 1864 z rzutem oka na calość dziejów porozbiorowych i sprawę włościańską. Kraków (in Polish).

Wolski, L., 1967. Powstanie polskie z roku 1863, z komentarzem mackiawela. Lwow (in Polish).
Published
2020-01-04
How to Cite
ZEMSKYI, Yurii S.; DIACHOK, Valerii V.. Narrative sources on the diplomatic game of European countries around the events of the Polish uprising of 1863. Universum Historiae et Archeologiae = The Universe of History and Archeology = Універсум історії та археології = Универсум истории и археологии ISSN 2664-9950 (Print) ISSN 2707-6385 (Online), [S.l.], v. 2, n. 1, p. 175–183, jan. 2020. ISSN 2707-6385. Available at: <http://uha.dp.ua/index.php/UHA/article/view/40>. Date accessed: 13 july 2020. doi: https://doi.org/10.15421/26190114.
Section
Historiography. Source Study. Special Historical Disciplines