"Ideological character" of M. P. Pogodin in the Pre-October and Soviet historiography

the main landmarks of the appraisal’s treatment

  • Mikhail A. Rudnev Oles Honchar Dnipro National University

Abstract

On the materials of the historico-biographical treaties and the generalizing works and special essays in history of the Russian social and political thought the historiographical appraisals and treatments of the ideological character of M. P. Pogodin given by the Pre-October and Soviet historians are examined. This problematico-historiographical review is realized in the context of phenomenon of the so-called «theory of the Official Nationality» in the period of the Nicholas I reign. A. N. Pypin, liberal and westernist historian of literature and social thought, was the real maker of this debatable historiographical ideological construction. He considered M. P. Pogodin the eminent representative of the Official Nationality and the odious conservator-conformist. Other Pre-October historians and publicists (S. Ashevskiy ets.) focused their research attention to Pogodin’s "Political letters" (1853−1856) in which his opposition to Nicholas I regime’s policy and certain progressive features of his position were especially strongly manifested. G. V. Plekhanov’s work "Pogodin and the class struggle" (1911) determined the typical for the following Marxist and Soviet historiography fixed interest to the class roots of his conservatism and sociological identification that as the "bourgeois". The late Soviet authors (V. K. Tereshchenko) which were adherents of the class treatment also and the contemporary Russian historians of the Soviet school (V. Ya. Grosul, R. G. Eymontova) emphasized the heterogeneity and evolutionary character of the Pogodin’s position, the increasing presence of the critical and progressive elements in his conservative world outlook on the whole.

Author Biography

Mikhail A. Rudnev, Oles Honchar Dnipro National University

PhD in History, Associate Professor, Associate Professor of the Department of Historiography, Source Studies and Archival Studies of the Oles Honchar Dnipro National University

References

Ashevskiy, S. [Stoliarov, M. N.]. (1900). Politicheskiye pisma Pogodina [Pogodin’s political letters]. Obrazovanie (12), 1−28 (in Russian).

Barsukov, N. P. (1899) Zhizn’ i trudy M. P. Pogodina: V 22 kn. [Life and works of M. P. Pogodin: in 22 books] (Book 13). Sankt-Petereburg (in Russian).

Vasetskiy, G. S. (Red) (1955). Ocherki po istorii philosophskoy i obshchestvennoy mysli narodov SSSR: v 2 t. [Essays on the history of the philosophical and social thought of the peoples of the USSR: in 2 volumes]. (Vol. 2). Moscow: Izdatelstvo AN SSSR (in Russian).

Grosul, V. Ya., Itenberg, B. S., Tvardovskaya, V. A., Shatsillo, K. F., Eymontova, R. G. (2000). Russkiy kon servatizm XIX stoletiya. Ideologiya i praktika. [Russian conservatism at the 19 th century. Ideology and practice]. Moscow: Progress-Traditsiya (in Russian).

Ospovat, A. L. (1989). Barsukov Nikolay Platonovich [Barsukov Nicholas Platonovich]. Russkiye pisateli [Russian writers]. 1800−1917. [Biographical Dictionary] (Vol. 4: M-P) 164−165. Moscow: Sovetskaya entsiklopediya (in Russian).

Plekhanov, G. V. (1923). Pogodin i borba klassov [Pogodin and the class struggle]. G. V. Plekhanov. Ocherki po istorii russkoy obshtvennoy mysli XIX veka. [Essays on the history of the Russian social thought of the 19th century], 28−67. Moskva: Priboy (in Russian).

Pokrovsky, V. S. (1952). Istoria russkoy politicheskoy mysli. (Konspekt lektsiy): in 3 vyp. [History of the Russian political thought.] (Summary of the lectures): in 3 parts. (Part 3). Moscow: Gosiunzdat (in Russian).

Pypin, A. N. (1909). Kharakteristiki literaturnykh mneniy ot dvadtsatykh do piatidesiatykh godov. [Descriptions of the literary opinions from the twenties to the fifties]. Sankt-Petereburg: Kolos (in Russian).

Rudnev, M. A. (2010). Istoriographicheskaya sud’ba slavianofilstva kak indicator poniatiya “russkiy conservatism” [Historiographical fate of the Slavophilism as the “indicator” of the conception “Russian conservatism”]. Visnyk Dnipropetrovs’kogo universitetu. Seria: Istoria ta arheologia. [Dnipropetrovsk University bulletin. History and archaeology series] 227−234 (in Russian).

Tereshchenko, V. K. (1975). Pogodin v obschestvenno-ideynoy borbe 30–50‑kh gg. XIX stoletiya. Avtoreferat dissertatsii na soiskanie stepeni kandidata istoricheskikh nauk [Pogodin in the social and political struggle at the 30−50 years of the XIX century. The dissertation author’s abstact on competition of a degree of the candidate of historical sciences]. Moscow: MGU (in Russian).

Tereshchenko, V. K. (1976). Pogodin i spory zapadnikov I slavianofilov v 1840-kh gg. [Pogodin and discussions of the Westernizers and the Slavophiles in the 1840 years]. Problemy istorii SSSR [Problems of history of the USSR] (5), 243−270 (in Russian).

Shiriniants, A. A. (2010). Pogodin Mikhail Petrovich [Pogodin Michael Petrovich]. Russkiy konservatizm serediny XVIII – nachala XVIII veka: entsiklopediya [Russian conservatism in the middle 18th – at the early 20th century. Encyclopaedia]. Moscow: ROSSPEN (in Russian).
Published
2019-12-29
How to Cite
RUDNEV, Mikhail A.. "Ideological character" of M. P. Pogodin in the Pre-October and Soviet historiography. Universum Historiae et Archeologiae = The Universe of History and Archeology = Універсум історії та археології = Универсум истории и археологии ISSN 2664-9950 (Print) ISSN 2707-6385 (Online), [S.l.], v. 1, n. 1-2, p. 102–109, dec. 2019. ISSN 2707-6385. Available at: <http://uha.dp.ua/index.php/UHA/article/view/20>. Date accessed: 22 oct. 2021. doi: https://doi.org/10.15421/2611812.
Section
Historiography. Source Study. Special Historical Disciplines