American Relief Administration (ARA) in Katerinoslav Region in 1922–1923: The Problem of Relations with the Government and the Population
Abstract
The aim of the article is an analytical reconstruction of the specific and contradictory dynamics of the ARA’s relations with local authorities and the population of Yekaterinoslav during the famine of 1921–1923. Research methods: dialectical, analytical, historical-systemic, comparative. Main results. It is established that during the years of independence domestic historiography has made a real breakthrough in the study of previously taboo topics of the so-called “naked nerves” of our Soviet history, in particular, the famine of 1921–1923 in the Southern Ukraine and the unique phenomenon of international support including Yekaterinoslav. It is proved that the undisputed leader among foreign charitable missions was the American Relief Administration (ARA), which effectively realized its powerful potential to create appropriate resources (financial, logistical, personnel), organized large-scale relief actions, saved lives of millions of Ukrainians. It is shown that the process of emergence, adaptation and deployment of ARA in the Yekaterinoslav region was not cloudless, sometimes contradictory, accompanied by certain misunderstandings and problematic situations in its relations with local authorities and the population, and even blocking certain actions of Americans. This course of events was largely explained by the novelty of the format of foreign humanitarian aid to starving citizens in the mysterious Bolshevik state, the manifestations of elements of ideological and mental “dissent”, suspicion and distrust on both sides. However, in general, this did not prevent the ARA branches from ensuring their uninterrupted and dynamic functioning throughout the campaign in order to organize broad support for the starving population of the Yekaterinoslav region and the Southern Ukraine. Originality: a significant array of mostly unpublished archival sources is discovered, systematized and impartially used. Scientific novelty: almost for the first time at the regional level the character, features and problematic situations in the relations of ARA with local authorities and the population of Yekaterinoslav region in the hungry 1922–1923 are revealed. Practical significance: the materials of the article can be used for further research of foreign charity organizations in Yekaterinoslav during the famine of the early 1920s, as well as during the writing of generalizing works on the history of the Soviet famines in Ukraine, in the educational process at the historical faculties of universities. Type of article: analytical.
References
Veselova, O. M., Marochko V. I., and Movchan O. M., 2000. Holodomory v Ukraini: 1921–1923, 1932–1933, 1946–1947: zlochyny proty narodu [The Holodomor in Ukraine: 1921–1923, 1932–1933, 1946–1947: crimes against the people]. Kyiv; N. Y.: M. P. Kots’. 174 p. (in Ukrainian).
Vidomosti pro punkty kharchuvannia, orhanizovani zakordonnymy orhanizatsiiamy, ta kil’kist’ liudej, iaki kharchuvalysia v nykh [Information on food outlets organized by foreign organizations and the number of people who ate at them]. File 265. Inventory 1. Fund 261. Kyiv: Tsentral’nyj derzhavnyj arkhiv vyschykh orhaniv vlady ta upravlinnia Ukrainy [Central State Archives of Supreme Bodies of Power and Government of Ukraine]. 197 pp. (in Russian).
Govorukha, V. A., 2020. Inozemna dopomoha ARA v Ukraini: radians’ka ta ukrains’ka istoriohrafiia [Foreign ARA assistance in Ukraine: Soviet and Ukrainian historiography]. Zaporizhzhia Historical Review, vol. 2 (54). Available at: https://istznu.org/index.php/journal/issue/view/29 [Accessed: 06.10.2021] (in Ukrainian).
Mel’nyk, O. O., comp., 2003. Holod: khronika, dokumenty ta materialy holodu 1921–1923, 1932–1933 rokiv na Kryvorizhzhi [Famine: chronicle, documents and materials on the famine of 1921–1923, 1932–1933 in Kryvyi Rih region. Kryvyj Rih: Vyd. Dim. 384 pp. (in Ukrainian).
Movchan, O. M., Oginskaya, A. P., and Yakovleva, L. V., 1993. Holod 1921–1923 rokiv v Ukraini [The famine of 1921–1923 in Ukraine]. Collection of documents and materials. Kyiv: Naukova dumka. 237 pp. (in Russian).
Holod v Ukraini u pershij polovyni XX stolittia: prychyny ta naslidky (1921–1923, 1932–1933, 1946–1947) [Famine in Ukraine in the first half of the 20th century. Causes and consequences (1921–1923, 1932–1933, 1946–1947)]. Materials of the international scientific conference. Kyiv. 364 pp. (in Ukrainian).
Holodomor 1921–1923 rr.: stolittia trahedii [The Holodomor of 1921–1923: the century of tragedy]. Available at: https://www.nbuv.gov.ua/node/5549 [Accessed: 08.10.2021] (in Ukrainian).
Dopovidi, zvity, koshtorysy Povnovazhenoho Predstavnyka Katerynoslavs’koi hubernii pro diial’nist’ Zakordonnykh orhanizatsij v dopomozi holoduiuchomu naselenniu hubernii. [Reports, estimates of the Plenipotentiary Representative of Ekaterinoslav Province on the activities of foreign organizations to help the starving population of the province]. File 122. Inventory 1. Fund 261. Kyiv: Tsentral’nyj derzhavnyj arkhiv vyschykh orhaniv vlady ta upravlinnia Ukrainy [Central State Archives of Supreme Bodies of Power and Government of Ukraine]. 116 pp. (in Russian).
Dramarets’kyj, B.B., 1997. Holod 1921–1923 rokiv v Ukraini [The famine of 1921–1923 in Ukraine]. Ph.D. (History) thesis. Kyiv. 123 p. (in Ukrainian).
Zvity pro diial’nist’ Hubekonomrady. Lystuvannia Hubkoma KP(b)U z Hubkobkomisiieiu dopomohy holoduiuchym. Zvedennia, dopovidi, zvity Huberns’koi komisii dopomohy holoduiuchym [Reports on the activities of the Regional Economic Council. Correspondence of the Provincial Committee of the CP (b) U with the Provincial Commission for Aid to the starving. Summaries and reports of the Provincial Commission for Aid to the Hungry]. File 968. Inventory 1. Fund 1. Dnipro: Derzhavnyi arkhiv Dnipropetrovskoi oblasti [State Archive of Dnipropetrovska oblast]. 224 pp. (in Russian).
Ivanenko, V. V., 2016. Holodne lykholittia 1921–1923 rokiv na Katerynoslavschyni: pohliad cherez desiatylittia [The famine of 1921–1923 in Yekaterinoslav region: a look through the decades]. Prydniprov’ia: istoryko-kraieznavchi doslidzhennia: zb. nauk. pr. [Prydniprovya: historical local lore investigations]. Dnipropetrovsk, issue 14, pp. 45–54. (in Ukrainian).
Ivanchenko, B. P., 2003. Vykorinennia: holodomory 1921–22, 1932–33 rr. v Dnipropetrovs’kij oblasti [Eradication: famines of 1921–22, 1932–33 in Dnipropetrovska oblast]. Pavlograd. 68 pp. (in Ukrainian).
Movchan, O. M., 2005. Inozemna dopomoha holoduiuchym v USRR, 1922–1923 [Foreign aid to the starving in the USSR, 1922–1923]. In: Smoliy, V. A., ed. in chief, 2005. Entsyklopediia istorii Ukrainy [Encyclopedia of the History of Ukraine]. In 12 vols. Kyiv: Naukova dumka, vol. 3, pp. 476–477 (in Ukrainian).
Kulchytsky, S. V., and Movchan, O. M., 1993. Nevidomi storinky holodu 1921–1923 rr. v Ukraini [Unknown pages of the famine of 1921–1923 in Ukraine]. Kyiv. 70 pp. (in Ukrainian).
Kulchytsky, S., 2013. Chervonyj vyklyk. Istoriia komunizmu v Ukraini vid joho narodzhennia do zahybeli [The Red Challenge. History of communism in Ukraine from its birth to its death]. In 3 vols. Kyiv, vol 2. 628 pp. (in Ukrainian).
Lystuvannia z Amerykans’koiu Administratsiieiu dopomohy pro metody i shliakhy dopomohy holoduiuchym, perevezennia, okhoronu ta rozghruzku produktiv i inshe [Correspondence with the US Aid Administration on methods and ways to help the starving, transportation, protection and unloading of food, etc.]. File 60. Inventory 1. Fund 261. Kyiv: Tsentral’nyj derzhavnyj arkhiv vyschykh orhaniv vlady ta upravlinnia Ukrainy [Central State Archives of Supreme Bodies of Power and Government of Ukraine]. 325 pp. (in Russian).
Mikhailovsky, T., 2009. ARA na Pivdni Ukrainy (1921–1923 rr.): istoriohrafiia problemy [ARA in the South of Ukraine (1921–1923): historiography of the problem]. Eminak. Scientific quarterly. Mykolaiv, no. 1–4, pp. 88–94 (in Ukrainian).
Mikhailovsky, T. O., 2017. Diial’nist’ mizhnarodnykh orhanizatsij na Pivdni Ukrainy (1921–1923 rr.) [Activities of international organizations in the South of Ukraine (1921–1923)]. Ph. D. (History) thesis. Mykolaiv. 266 p. (in Ukrainian).
Movchan, O. M., 2001. Amerykans’ka administratsiia dopomohy [American Aid Administration]. Available at: https://esu.com.ua/search_articles.php?id=43986 [Accessed: 06.10.2021] (in Ukrainian).
Moriak [Sailor], 1923, no. 307, February 4 (in Russian).
Patenaude, B. M., 2002. The Big Show in Bololand. The American Relief Expedition to Soviet Russia in the Famine of 1921. Stanford: Stanford University Press. 817 pp.
Pidmohylny, V., 1991. Syn. Opovidannia, povisti, romany [Son. Stories, short stories, novels]. Kyiv, Naukova dumka, pp. 138–156 (in Ukrainian).
Rabochiy put [Working way], 1922, no. 6 (347), July 3 (in Russian).
Starodubov, A.F., 2001. Zapiski ochevidtsa: Yekaterinoslav 1918–1923 [Eyewitness Notes: Yekaterinoslav 1918–1923]. Dnepropetrovsk: Gaudeamus. 230 p. (in Russian).
Telehramy Katerynoslavs’koho upovnovazhenoho Dopholodu pro vydilennia koshtiv, perevezennia vantazhu i in.; vidomist’ pro vyplatu zarplaty pratsivnykam ARA ta spysok studentiv Katerynoslavs’koho robitnychoho tekhnikumu [Telegrams of the Katerynoslav Commissioner Dopgolod on the allocation of funds, transportation of goods, etc.; information on the payment of salaries to ARA employees and the list of students of Ekaterinoslav Workers’ Technical School]. File 60. Inventory 1. Fund 261. Kyiv: Tsentral’nyj derzhavnyj arkhiv vyschykh orhaniv vlady ta upravlinnia Ukrainy [Central State Archives of Supreme Bodies of Power and Government of Ukraine]. 197 pp. (in Russian).
Telehramy Povpreda po Katerynoslavs’kij hubernii t. Skvortsova z pytan’ rozpodilu posylok sered naselennia, okhorony prodovol’choho vantazhu ta joho perevezennia i inshe [Telegrams of the Commissar Comrade Skvortsov in Ekaterinoslav Province on the distribution of parcels among the population, protection of food cargo and its transportation, etc.]. File 38. Inventory 1. Fund 261. Kyiv: Tsentral’nyj derzhavnyj arkhiv vyschykh orhaniv vlady ta upravlinnia Ukrainy [Central State Archives of Supreme Bodies of Power and Government of Ukraine]. 114 pp. (in Russian).
Fisher, H., 1971. The Famine in the Soviet Russia. The Operations of the American Relief Administration. N. Y. 630 рp.
Phillips, H. D., 1992. Between the Revolution and the West. A Political Biography of Maxim M. Litvinov. Westview Press. 147 p.
Shityuk, M., and Gorburov, K., 2007. Mykolaivschyna v holodnykh 1921–1923, 1932–1933, 1946–1947 rokakh [Mykolayiv region in the famine of 1921–1923, 1932–1933, 1946–1947]. Mykolaiv. 156 pp. (in Ukrainian).
Authors who are published in the journal «Universum Historiae et Archeologiae» agree to the following terms:
– copyright on the article is retained by the author(s); the authors grant the right of the first publication to the journal «Universum Historiae et Archeologiae». After submitting his text to the editorial board, the author of the article should not violate the copyrights of other individuals and organizations;
– the author of the published article has the right to distribute it in the form in which it is published in the journal «Universum Historiae et Archeologiae» (for example, to post the article in repositories, personal scientific profiles, websites or publish as a part of a monograph), provided that the bibliographic links to the first publication of the work in the journal «Universum Historiae et Archeologiae» are present (or links to an electronic copy, which is stored on the official website of the journal).
