Evolution of Volodymyr Vynnychenko’s political views in 1920 in the context of the crisis of the Soviet form of the Ukrainian state
The article is devoted to the relations between Volodymyr Vynnychenko and Lev Trotsky – leading figures of the revolutionary period of 1917–1921. The 1920s were one of the most difficult and controversial periods in the life of Volodymyr Vynnychenko. Formulation of the problem. There are many versions and assumptions about the reasons for V. Vynnychenko’s break with the Bolsheviks: from his careerism to his unwillingness to be a screen for Bolshevik policy in Ukraine, which actually destroyed his political dream – the creation of independent Soviet Ukraine. V. Vynnychenko’s decision is hotly debated, both among professional historians, educators, and among ordinary readers, users of social networks, and various historical groups. The aim of the research is to find out the reasons for the evolution of V. Vynnychenko’s political worldview and the influence of Lev Trotsky on these changes. The main results. The author draws attention to L. Trotsky’s influence, both on the fact of V. Vynnychenko’s return from emigration and on his coming abroad. The documents were signed by L. Trotsky and conversations with him had a significant impact on V. Vynnychenko’s decision, as evidenced by entries in his diary, the book “Renaissance of the Nation” and his autobiography. Influenced by these texts and meetings, V. Vynnychenko realized that the Bolsheviks’ recognition of Soviet Ukraine’s right to independence was a declaration of intent, not a real policy. At the same time, V. Vynnychenko himself believed that his views also influenced Trotsky’s political worldview, which in the 1930s began to criticize Bolshevik centralism and their policy toward Ukraine’s sovereign status. The study is based on a variety of sources. The author uses the methods of comparative analysis, microhistory, biography, applies a regional approach, drawing attention to the fellowship of V. Vynnychenko, L. Trotsky, G. Zinoviev, influential politicians of the revolutionary period of 1917–1921. Concise conclusions. V. Vynnychenko’s contradictory, sometimes difficult to understand, decisions in 1920 received different assessments from representatives of modern Ukrainian historiography. Some historians believe that V. Vynnychenko outplayed himself, i. e. the Bolsheviks used him to propagate Soviet power in Ukraine, and his hesitations had a negative impact on the development of the Ukrainian revolution in 1920. Other historians try to explain V. Vynnychenko’s steps by trying to reach an agreement with the Bolsheviks to implement his plan, which was to put into practice the idea of Ukrainian statehood in the Soviet form. The study is based on a variety of sources (the diary entries of Vladimir Vynnychenko during 1920, his leaflets, analytical memoirs given in the book “Renaissance of the Nation”, published in 1920, his autobiography, information reports of the Political Department of the UPR, which mention the name of V. Vynnychenko, and also the journalistic legacy of Lev Trotsky, devoted to the question of the independence of Soviet Ukraine). Scientific novelty and originality. For the first time in historiography, the author draws attention to the mutual influences of V. Vynnychenko and L. Trotsky on the evolution of their political worldview. The type of article: theoretical.
Vynnychenko, V., 1990. Vidrodzhennia natsii [Rebirth of the nation]. In 3 parts. Kyiv; Vienna. Part 3. 542 p. (in Ukrainian).
Vynnychenko, V., 1980. Schodennyk [Diary]. In 6 vols. Ed. by H. Kostiuk. Edmonton; N. Y., vol. 1: 1911–1920. 500 p. (in Ukrainian).
Vynnychenko, V., 2010. Schodennyk [Diary]. In 4 vols. Ed. by H. Kostiuk. Kyiv, vol 3: 1926–1928. 624 p. (in Ukrainian).
Vynnychenko, V., 1920. Revoliutsiia v nebezpetsi (Lyst zakordonnoi hrupy UKP do komunistiv i revoliutsijnykh sotsialistiv Yevropy i Ameryky) [Revolution in Danger (Letter of the UCP Foreign Group to the Communists and Revolutionary Socialists of Europe and America)]. Available at: https://diasporiana.org.ua/ideologiya/vynnychenko-v-revolyucziya-v-nebezpeczi-lyst-zak-grupy-ukp-do-komunistiv-i-revolyuczijnyh-socziyalistiv-Evropy-ta-Ameryky/ [Accessed: 02.02.2021] (in Ukrainian).
Hrynevych, V., 2012. Nepryborkane riznoholossia. Druha svitova vijna i suspil’no-politychni nastroi v Ukraini, 1939 – cherven’ 1941 rr.[Unbridled dissent. The World War II and socio-political sentiment in Ukraine, 1939 – 1941, June ]. Kyiv; Dnipropetrovsk: Lira. 508 p. (in Ukrainian).
Yefimenko, H., 2012. Status USRR ta ii vzaiemovidnosyny z RSFRR: dovhyj 1920 rik [The status of the USSR and its relationship with the RSFSR: a long 1920]. Ed. by S. Kul’chyts’kyj. Kyiv: NAN Ukrainy. Instytut istorii Ukrainy. 367 p. (in Ukrainian).
Kostiuk, H., 1980. Volodymyr Vynnychenko ta joho doba [Volodimir Vynnychenko and his time]. N. Y. 283 p. (in Ukrainian).
Mytrofanenko, Yu., 2020. “Syfilis rus’koho shovinizmu”. Yak Vynnychenko z bil’shovyka peretvoryvsia na “voroha pratsiuiuchykh mas” [“Syphilis of Russian chauvinism”. How Vynnychenko turned from a Bolshevik into an “enemy of the working masses”]. Available at: https://www.dsnews.ua/ukr/nasha_revolyutsiya_1917/sifilis-ruskogo-shovinizmu-yak-vinnichenko-z-bilshovika-peretvorivsya-na-voroga-pracyuyuchih mas-11112020–405757 [Accessed: 02.02.2021] (in Ukrainian).
Kul’chyts’kyj, S., 2019. Volodymyr Vynnychenko : buty chesnym z soboiu … [Volodimir Vynnychenko : to be honest with yourself …]. NAN Ukrainy. Instytut politychnykh i etnonatsional’nykh doslidzhen’ im. I. F. Kurasa. Kyiv: Parlam. vyd-vo. 512 p. (in Ukrainian).
Soldatenko, V., 2005. Try Holhofy: politychna dolia Volodymyra Vynnychenka [Three Calvaries: the political destiny of Volodymyr Vynnychenko]. Kyiv: Svitohliad. 349 p. (in Ukrainian).
Soldatenko, V., 2007. Vynnychenko i Petliura: politychni portrety revoliutsijnoi doby [Vynnychenko and Petliura: political portraits of the revolutionary era]. Kyiv: Svitohliad. 621 p. (in Ukrainian).
Panchenko, V., 2004. Volodymyr Vynnychenko: paradoksy doli i tvorchosti. Knyha rozvidok ta mandrivok [Volodymyr Vynnychenko: Paradoxes of Fate and Creativity. A Book of Explorations and Travels]. Kyiv: Tviminter. 288 p. (in Ukrainian).
Mytrofanenko, Y., ed., 2020. Roky borot’by 1917–1922 rr. na Yelysavetchyni. Ukrains’kyj pohliad. Rik 1920. Proty bilykh i chervonykh okupantiv [Years of struggle 1917–1922 in Yelisavetchyna. Ukrainian view. Year 1920. Against the white and red occupiers]. Kropyvnyts’kyj: Imeks-LTD. The 3d book. 276 p. (in Ukrainian).
Trotskyj, L., 1991. Moia zhyzn’ [My life]. Moscow: Panorama. 623 p. (in Russian).
Trotsʹkiy, L., 1939. Pro ukrainske pitannj [About the Ukrainian question]. Available at: https://www.istpravda.com.ua/articles/2013/11/20/139689/ [Accessed: 01.02.2021] (in Ukrainian).