The monograph by D. Y. Samokvasov “Ancient towns of Russia” (1873) in the light of criticism of F. I. Leontovich

Abstract

The purpose of the article: to analyze the scientific controversy between F. Leontovich and D. Samokvasov, which arose on the monograph of D. Samokvasov “Ancient cities of Russia” (St. Petersburg, 1873). Research methods: analytical, historical, biographical, problematic-historiographic, descriptive. Main results: the beginning of the scientific controversy between D. Samokvasov and F. Leontovich, which arose over D. Samokvasov’s monograph “Ancient Cities of Russia” (St. Petersburg, 1873), was laid by a review written by F. Leontovich. According to the reviewer, D. Samokvasov’s doctrine of the historical development of the concept of the city was marked by confusion of concepts and definitions. F. Leontovych considered the author’s position on the historical origin and role of ancient Russian positions to be based on incorrectly interpreted historical evidence. Among the reasons he named complete ignorance of historical facts or simple disregard of them. The reviewer considered the first chapter of the monograph devoted to determining the number of towns in Ancient Russia the best part of the work, but, in his opinion, the author stopped halfway, he did not explain exactly what these cities were – simple fortifications or fortified points of people’s settlement. D. Samokvasov’s own views on the time of the initial emergence of cities and on the historical development of popular settlements in Russia, considered in the second chapter of the monograph, without exception, generated, as F. Leontovich believed, doubts, misunderstandings and controversial points. The reviewer did not agree with the author’s statement that the city was a center of community unity, and that with its appearance began a transitional period between the forms of patrimonial way of life and community-state life. The main thesis proposed by D. Samokvasov’s theory that in the pre-Moscow period in Russia urban life prevailed everywhere, and rural began to prevail only in the 16th century, F. Leontovich declared to be based only on questionable or misunderstood historical evidences. In addition to criticism of the main provisions of D. Samokvasov’s conceptual scheme, the reviewer presented his own understanding of this topic. In response to the review by F. Leontovich, D. Samokvasov did not agree with his criticism. He stated that the reviewer had neglected the true content of the monograph and therefore could hardly write a thorough, useful scientific review. D. Samokvasov believed that his research deserved a more thorough study and more serious and just estimation. In his reply to D. Samokvasov F. Leontovich criticized his polemic tricks and did not reject any of his critical remarks. The original continuation of this scientific discussion was the monograph by D. Samokvasov “Severian Land and Severians on the Towns and Burial Grounds”, published in 1908. After thirty years the researcher categorically declared that it is impossible to refute fundamentally the conclusions of his theory, because they are based on irrefutable factual material. D. Samokvasov called the scientific theory of his opponents unsubstantiated. Practical significance: the received results can be used in training courses and generalizing works on the history of Ukraine and its historiography, especially on the historiography and history of the ancient Russian city. Originality: scientific polemic between F. Leontovich and D. Samokvasov concerning the monography “Ancient cities of Russia” is systemized and analyzed. Scientific novelty: the scientific polemic between F. Leontovich and D. Samokvasov concerning the monography “Ancient cities of Russia” is thoroughly and as much as possible comprehensively opened and analyzed. Type of article: research.

Author Biography

Vitalii Yatsenko, Oles Honchar Dnipro National University

Ph. D. in History, Associate Professor, Associate Professor at the Department of History of Eastern Europe, Oles Honchar Dnipro National University

References

Berdinskih, V. A., 2001. Shchavelev, S. P. Istorik Russkoj zemli (zhizn’ i trudy D. Ya. Samokvasova). Kursk: Izd-vo Kurskogo med. un-ta, 1998. 282 s. (Rec.) [Shchavelev S. P. The Historian of Russian earth (life and D. Y. Samokvasov’s works). Kursk: Publishing house Kursk medical un-ty, 1998. 282 p. (Review)]. Voprosy istorii [History questions]. Moscow, no. 8, pp. 159–160 (in Russian).

Brajchevs’ka, O. A., 1996. Samokvasov Dmy’tro Yakovy’ch [Samokvasov Dmitry Yakovlevich]. Ukrayins’ka biografisty’ka: zb. nauk. pracz’ [Ukrainian biographistics. The collection of proceedings]. Kyyiv, issue 1, pp. 96–99 (in Ukrainian).

Golotvin, A. N., 2014. D. Ya. Samokvasov i izuchenie slavyano-russkih drevnostej [D. Y. Samokvasov and studying of Slavic-and-Russian antiquities]. Voronezh: Publishing-polygraphic centre “Scientific book” (in Russian).

Grushevs’ky’j, M. S., 1911. F. Leontovy’ch – V. Klyuchevs’ky’j – D. Samokvasov [F. Leontovich – V. Kljuchevsky – D. Samokvasov]. Zapy’sky’ NTSh [Notes of Scientific organisation of a name of Shevchenko]. Lviv, vol. 105, book 5, pp. 168–174 (in Ukrainian).

Lapteva, T. A., Eskin, Yu. M., 2000. Kniga o vydayushchemsya arheologe i arhiviste (Shchavelev S. P. Istorik Russkoj zemli: Zhizn’ i Trudy D. Ya. Samokvasova. Kursk: Izd-vo Kurskogo med. un-ta, 1998. – 281 s. (Rec.) [The book about the outstanding archeologist and the archivist. (Shchavelev S. P. The Historian of Russian earth: Life and D. Y. Samokvasov’s works. Kursk: Publishing house Kursk medical un-ty, 1998. 281 p. (Review)]. Otechestvennaya istoriya [National history]. Moscow, no. 6, pp. 186–187 (in Russian).

Lebedev, V. B., 2003. Arhiv Samokvasova ne sohranilsya [Samokvasov’s archive has not remained]. Voprosy istorii [History questions]. Moscow, no. 3, pp. 174–175 (in Russian).

Leontovich, F., 1877. Vozrazhenie g. Samokvasovu [Objection Samokvasovu]. Sbornik gosudarstvennyh znanij [The collection of the state knowledge]. St. Petersburg, vol. 3, pp. 29–36. Available at: http://starieknigi.info/Knigi/B/Bezobrazov_V_P_Sbornik_gosudarstvennyh_znanij_03_1877.pdf [Accessed: 23.03.2021] (in Russian).

Leontovich, F., 1875. Drevnie goroda Rossii. Istoriko-yuridicheskoe issledovanie D. Ya. Samokvasova. St. Petersburg 1873 [Ancient cities of Russia. D. Y. Samokvasov’s Istoriko-legal research. St. Petersburg 1873]. Sbornik gosudarstvennyh znanij [The collection of the state knowledge]. St. Petersburg, vol. 2, pp. 35–91. Available at: http://starieknigi.info/Knigi/B/Bezobrazov_V_P_Sbornik_gosudarstvennyh_znanij_02_1875.pdf [Accessed: 23.03.2021] (in Russian).

Mihal’chenko, S. I., 1996. Metodologiya tvorchestva F. I. Leontovicha [Methodology of creativity of F. I. Leontovich]. Іstorіya. Chastyna 1: Tezi ta povіdomlennya ІІІ Mіzhnarodnogo kongresu ukraїnіstіv, 26–29 serpnya 1996 r. [History. A part 1. Theses and messages of the Third International congress Ukrainians, 26–29 August 1996]. Kharkіv: Oko, pp. 175–177 (in Russian).

Muzy’chko, O. Ye., 2003a. Vy’svitlennya tvorchosti F. I. Leontovy’cha v istoriografiyi [Studying of creativity of F. I. Leontovich in a historiography]. Pivdenny’j arxiv: zb. nauk. pracz’. Istory’chni nauky’ [Southern archive: The collection of proceedings. Historical sciences]. Kherson, issue 10, pp. 31–36 (in Ukrainian).

Muzy’chko, O. Ye., 2003b. Vnesok F. I. Leontovy’cha u rozrobku teorety’chny’x problem istory’chnoyi nauky’ [F. I. Leontovich’s contribution to working out of theoretical problems of a historical science]. Zapy’sky’ istory’chnogo fakul’tetu ONU im. I. I. Mechny’kova [Notes of historical faculty ONU of a name of I. I. Mechnikov]. Odesa, issue 14, pp. 248–261 (in Ukrainian).

Samokvasov, D. Ya., 1873. Drevnie goroda Rossii. Istoriko-yuridicheskoe issledovanie [Ancient cities of Russia. Istoriko-legal research]. St. Petersburg: K. Zamyslovsky’s printing house. Available at: http://starieknigi.info/Knigi/S/Samokvasov_D_Ya_Drevnie_goroda_Rossii_1873.pdf
[Accessed: 23.03.2021] (in Russian).

Samokvasov, D., 1877a. Drevnie goroda Rossii. (Sborn. Gos. Zn. II tom; recenziya F. I. Leontovicha na knigu D. YA. Samokvasova “Drevnie goroda Rossii”) [Ancient cities of Russia. (The collection of the state knowledge. The 2nd volume; F. I. Leontovich’s review of D. Y. Samokvasov’s book “Ancient cities of Russia”)]. Sbornik gosudarstvennyh znanij [The collection of the state knowledge]. St. Petersburg, vol. 3, pp. 24–29. Available at: http://starieknigi.info/Knigi/B/Bezobrazov_V_P_Sbornik_gosudarstvennyh_znanij_03_1877.pdf [Accessed: 23.03.2021] (in Russian).

Samokvasov D., 1877b. O drevnih gorodah Rossii (Otvet F. I. Leontovichu po povodu stat’i ego v t. ІІ „Sb. Gos. Zn.”) [About ancient cities of Russia (Answer to F. I. Leontovich concerning its article in v. ІІ “The collection of the state knowledge”)]. Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosveshcheniya [Magazine of the Ministry of national
education]. St. Petersburg, issue CXC, part 2, pp. 254–306, Available at: https://runivers.ru/upload/iblock/b3b/190.pdf [Accessed: 21.03.2021] (in Russian).

Samokvasov, D., 1908. Severyanskaya zemlya i Severyane po gorodishcham i mogilam [The Severjansky earth and Severjans on sites of ancient settlement and tombs]. Moscow: Synod printing house. Available at: http://starieknigi.info/Knigi/S/Samokvasov_D_JA_Severjanskaja_zemlja_i_Severjane_po_gorodishcham_i_mogilam_1908.pdf [Accessed: 20.03.2021] (in Russian).

F. I. Leontovy’ch (1833–1910): bibliografichny’j pokazhchy’k [F. I. Leontovich (1833–1910): the bibliographic index], 2005. Odesa (in Ukrainian).

Horhordina, T. I., 2000. D. Ya. Samokvasov: konservator-reformator [D. Y. Samokvasov: the conservative-reformer]. Otechestvennye arhivy [Domestic archives], Moscow, no. 2, pp. 26–41 (in Russian).

Shchavelev, S. P., 1993a. D. Ya. Samokvasov – istorik, arheolog, arhivist (1843–1911) [D. Y. Samokvasov – the historian, the archeologist, the archivist (1843–1911)]. Voprosy istorii [History questions], Moscow, no. 3, pp. 177–183 (in Russian).

Shchavelev, S. P., 1998. Istorik Russkoj zemli: Zhizn’ i trudy D. Ya. Samokvasova [The historian of Russian earth : Life and D. Y. Samokvasov’s works]. Kursk : Publishing house Kursk medical un-ty (in Russian).

Shchavelev, S. P., 1993b. Epizody istorii russkoj arheologii: (k 190-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya D. Ya. Samokvasova) [Episodes of history of Russian archeology: (to the 190 anniversary from the date of D. Y. Samokvasov’s birth)]. Rossijskaya arheologiya [Russian archeology], Moscow, no. 1, pp. 221–235 (in Russian).

Shhavel’ov, S. P., 1991. D. Ya. Samokvasov: Zapovit arkheologa [D. Y. Samokvasov: the Will of the archeologist]. Arkheologiya [Archeology]. Kyiv, no. 1, pp. 98–108 (in Ukrainian).

Shhavel’ov, S. P., 1994. Ukrayins’ka arxeologiya v ly’stuvanni D. Ya. Samokvasova [The Ukrainian archeology in D. Y. Samokvasov’s correspondence]. Arkheologiya [Archeology]. Kyiv, no. 1, pp. 115–131 (in Ukrainian).
Published
2021-12-25
How to Cite
YATSENKO, Vitalii. The monograph by D. Y. Samokvasov “Ancient towns of Russia” (1873) in the light of criticism of F. I. Leontovich. Universum Historiae et Archeologiae, [S.l.], v. 4, n. 1, p. 121–135, dec. 2021. ISSN 2707-6385. Available at: <http://uha.dp.ua/index.php/UHA/article/view/124>. Date accessed: 22 jan. 2022. doi: https://doi.org/10.15421/26210404.
Section
Historiography. Source Study. Special Historical Disciplines