Marxism, nationalism and modernization processes in Eastern Europe in the middle of 19th – early 20th century
The aim of the article is to elucidate the impact of Marxism and Nationalism on modernization processes in Eastern Europe from the perspective of their formation and mutual influence. Research methods: synthesis, induction, analysis, retrospective. Main results. During research we studied programs of both ideologies and compared their distinctive traits. Through analysis oftheoretical patterns of nationalism movements, different theories of public modernization and European point of view about backwardness, we found that Nationalism and Marxism significantly diverged around the role of statehood in culture and political changes. For Nationalism – state was the main aim and, simultaneously, result of nationalist movement activity. Further progress of nation was related to national state, which could provide certain conditions for cultural and economic development. Statehood in Marxists views was unwelcome; changes in society were related to social revolutionary movements without creation new state formations. State’s participation in transformation processes was, in theory, different for both ideologies. But when communists seized a power in the former Russian Empire, they faced a necessity of making their own statehood with its national policy. In fact, Nationalism became an artificial method on the way towards modernization of society. In conclusion, Eastern Europe modernization happened due to unification of communist and nationalist political thought. Scientific novelty of the paper is explained by analysis of works by Austrian Marxists, who made a theory for Soviet national policy. We explain this point by comparing some Austrian ideas to J. Stalin’s view on national question. The author also advocates the idea of existence some nationalistic traits during socialistic modernization in the USSR. Practical value of the research is a creation of background for studying Soviet ideology from new point of view. Type of article: empirical research.
Bauer, O., 2002. Naczional’ny’j vopros i soczial-demokratiya [The National Question and Social Democracy]. In: Anderson B., Bauer O., and Hroh M., 2002. Natsii i natsionalism [Nations and nationalism]. Moscow: Praksis, pp. 52–120 (in Russian).
Brubaker, R., 2012. Etnichnost bez grup [Ethnicity without borders]. Moscow. Publisher house “Higher school of economics” (in Russian).
Wolff, L., 2003. Izobretaya Vostochnuyu Evropu. Karta tsivilizatsii v soznanii epokhi Prosveshcheniya [Inventing Eastern Europe: The Map of Civilization on the Mind of the Enlightenment]. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie (in Russian).
Gellner, E., 1991. Natsii i natsionalizm [Nations and nationalism]. Translated from English by I. Krupnik. Moscow: Progress (in Russian).
Gershenkron, A., 2015. E А. Ekonomicheskaya otstalost v istoricheskoy perspektive [Economic backwardness in historical perspective]. Publishing house “Delo” (in Russian).
Calhoun, C., 2006. Natsionalism [Nationalism]. Moscow: Publishing house “Territoriya budushchego” (in Russian).
Kappeler, А., 2005. Rosiia yak polietnichna imperiia. Vynyknennia. Istoriia. Rozpad [Russia as a Multi‑ethnic Empire. Origin. History. Desintegration]. Translated from German by H. Nazarkevich. Lviv: Publishing house of Ukraine Catholic University (in Ukrainian).
Kasianov, G., 1999. Teorii natsii ta natsionalizmu [Theories of nation and nationalism]. Kyiv: Lybid (in Ukrainian).
Kedourie, E., 2010. Natsionalism [Nationalism]. St. Petersburg: Alateyya (in Russian).
Korzhikhina, T., 1994. Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i ego uchrezhdeniya: noyabr 1917 – dekabr 1991g. [Soviet state and its institutions: November 1917 – December 1991]. Moscow: RGGU (in Russian).
Martin, T., 2011. Imperiya “polozhitelnoy deyatel’nosti”. Natsii i natsionalizm v SSSR, 1923–1939 [The Affirmative Action Empire. Nations and Nationalism in the USSR, 1923–1939]. Moscow: ROSSPEN (in Russian).
Mace, J., 2018. Komunіzm ta dilemi natsіonal’nogo vizvolennya: Natsіonal’niy komunіzm u Radyans’kіy Ukraїnі, 1918–1933 [Communism and the Dilemmas of National Liberation: National Communism in Soviet Ukraine 1918–1933]. Kyiv: Komora (in Ukrainian).
Nisbet, R., 2007. Progress: istoriya idei [History of the Idea of Progress]. Moscow: IRISEN (in Russian).
Smith, Anthoni D., 2004. Natsionalizm i modernizm: Kriticheskiy obzor sovremennykh teoriy natsiy i natsionalizma [Nationalism and Modernism. Critical review of Contemporary Theories of Nation and Nationalism]. Moscow: Praksis (in Russian).
Stalin, J., 1946. Marksizm i natsional’nyy vopros [Marxism and National Question]. Full set of works in 18 volumes. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury, vol. 2 (1907–1913) (in Russian).
Hobsbawm, E., 1998. Natsii i natsionalizm posle 1780 g. [Nation and Nationalism since 1780]. St. Petersburg: Alateyya (in Russian).
Hroh, M., 2002. Ot natsionalnykh dvizheniy k polnost’yu sformirovavsheysya natsii: protsess stroitel’stva natsiy v Evrope [From National Movements to Completely Emerged Nations: The Nation Building Process in Europe]. In: Anderson, B., Bauer, O., and Hroh, M., 2002. Natsii i natsionalism [Nations and nationalism]. Moscow: Praksis, pp. 121–145 (in Russian).
Shporlyuk, R., 1998. Komunіzm і natsіonalіzm. Karl Marks protiv Frіdrіkha Lіsta [Communism and Nationalism: Carl Marx versus Friedrich List]. Kyiv (in Ukrainian).
Shporlyuk, R., 1990. Pol’shcha. Teorіya ta praktika modernoї natsії 1770–1870 [Poland. Theory and Practice of Modern Nation 1770–1870]. In: Shporlyuk R., 2016. Formuvannya modernikh natsіi Ukraina – Rosіya – Polshcha [Emerge of Modern Nations: Ukraine – Russia – Poland]. Kyiv: DUKH І LІTERA, pp. 92–120 (in Ukrainian).
Shpringer, R., 2010. Natsional’naya problema: bor’ba natsional’nostey v Avstrii [National Problem. National Struggle in Austria]. Translated from German by M. Ratner.
Moscow: Krasand (in Russian).
Engels, F., 1961. Anti-Dyuring. Full set of works in 55 volumes. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury, vol. 20 (in Russian).
Engels, F., 1961. Pol’skaya proklamatsiya [Political Proclamation]. Full set of works in 55 volumes. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury, vol. 18 (in Russian).
Engels, F., 1955. Printsipy kommunizma [Communism principles]. Full set of works in 55 volumes. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury, vol. 4 (in Russian).
Hroh, M., 1985. Social preconditions of national revival in Europe. Cambridge university press.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.